How to keep a forex trading journal
A forex trading journal is a record of every trade you take: what you traded, why, how much you risked and what happened. Kept for a few weeks, it shows which setups pay and which quietly cost money, which a list of closed trades alone will not tell you. On a prop firm evaluation it does one more job: it tracks how close you are to each limit. NextGen Funding, backed by Errante, publishes fixed limits for all three challenges, so they fit neatly into a journal. This guide gives the columns, a full week of entries on the evaluation for a 25k funded account, and the arithmetic that turns those entries into a plan.
What MT5 records and what it leaves out
MetaTrader 5 (MT5) is the platform behind every NextGen Funding account, and it already logs the hard data. Right-click the History tab and choose Report, and MT5 builds a history report with your orders, deals, open positions, balance and statistics such as profit factor and drawdown. MetaQuotes defines the result of each deal there as profit minus commission, fees and swap, so the costs are already inside the numbers.
What MT5 cannot know is the part that improves your trading. It has no field for the setup you traded, the session, whether you followed your plan, or how close the day came to your daily loss limit. Those columns are the journal.
The columns worth keeping
| Column | What to write | Why it matters on an evaluation |
|---|---|---|
| Date and session | Day, time in UTC, session | Shows which hours make or lose money |
| Setup | A short name, the same every time | Lets you total results by setup later |
| Risk | Dollars at the stop, and that amount as 1R | Keeps results comparable as the balance changes |
| Result | Net dollars and the result in R | R shows quality, dollars show progress |
| Day total | Running net result for the day | Shows how much of the daily loss limit is used |
| Floor distance | Equity minus the maximum drawdown floor | The number that ends an account if it reaches zero |
| News check | Was a high-impact release within 2 minutes? | Rapid, Ace and funded accounts restrict that window |
| Plan followed? | Yes or no, plus one line | The column that changes behaviour |
Keep each entry short. Two lines written straight after the trade beat a long note written at the weekend from memory.
A week of entries on a $25,000 Standard account
Take a trader in Phase 1 of a $25,000 Standard prop firm challenge. The target is 10%, or $2,500, the daily loss limit is 5%, or $1,250, and the maximum drawdown floor is $22,500. Each trade risks 0.5% of the account, $125, with a 25-pip stop on EUR/USD. With $10 per pip for a full lot, that comes to 0.5 lots, so the commission is $1.50 per trade. Our pip value guide explains the lot calculation.
| Day | Trades | Result in R | Result before costs | Journal note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Monday | 2 | +1.0R | +$125 | London breakout paid, afternoon fade stopped out |
| Tuesday | 2 | -2.0R | -$250 | Both trades taken in the Asian range, before London |
| Wednesday | 1 | +1.5R | +$187.50 | One trade in the London and New York overlap |
| Thursday | 3 | +2.0R | +$250 | Two winners, one early entry |
| Friday | 1 | -1.0R | -$125 | Flat before the US jobs report, loss came earlier |
| Week | 9 | +1.5R | +$187.50 | Commission $13.50, net +$174 |
The worst day used $250 of the $1,250 daily allowance, a fifth of it, and equity never came near the floor. On risk, the week was clean. On progress, it was slow.

Turning the journal into numbers
Four wins averaged 1.63R and five losses averaged 1R, a 44% win rate. Expectancy is the net result divided by the number of trades: $174 over 9 trades, or about $19 per trade after commission. At that rate the $2,500 target needs about 130 trades, roughly 14 weeks at 9 trades a week. Standard has no time limit, so that is allowed, but it is a long road.
Now read the notes column. Both Tuesday losses came from the same setup, traded before London opened. Remove those two trades and the week becomes 3.5R over 7 trades, $427 net, about $61 per trade. That puts the target about 41 trades away, or around 6 weeks. One change, found in the journal, cut the time to target by more than half. A week is a small sample, so check the same pattern over a month before treating it as proven.
A review routine that fits an evaluation
- After each trade, fill in the row before opening the next one.
- At the end of each day, write the day total and the floor distance.
- Once a week, total the results by setup and by session.
- Change one thing at a time, and mark the date of the change in the journal.
- Before buying the next account size, compare at least 30 trades.
For a step-by-step plan built around these limits, see how to pass a prop firm challenge.
Extra columns for a funded account
On a simulated funded account two more checks matter. First, news trading is no longer allowed on any funded account, even one reached through Standard, so the news column becomes a hard rule. Second, a payout request needs your best day to be no more than 50% of the total profit, so add a column for the best day so far. Once the best day is no more than half of the total, the request can go in, and NextGen Funding processes it within 24 to 48 hours of submission.
Over a longer stretch, the same journal shows whether you are on pace for the scaling plan, which reviews every four months and adds 25% of the initial balance when the cycle shows at least 10% net profit (at least 2.5% per month) and at least one completed withdrawal.
Frequently asked questions
What should a forex trading journal include?
At minimum the date, pair, setup, risk in dollars, result in dollars and in R, and whether you followed your plan. For an evaluation, add the daily total and the distance to the drawdown floor.
Is a spreadsheet good enough?
Yes. A spreadsheet with the columns above does everything most traders need, and it is easy to total by setup or session.
Can I use the MT5 history instead of a journal?
Use it as the data source for the journal. The MT5 report gives accurate results after costs, but it does not record why you took a trade or whether it followed your plan.
What does expectancy tell me?
The average amount you make or lose per trade. A positive number means your method has made money over the sample, and dividing your remaining target by it estimates how many trades are left.
Do I need a journal for the NextGen Funding challenge?
It is not one of the NextGen Funding rules. Still, a journal is the simplest way to see how close you are to the published limits each day.
How many trades before I trust the numbers?
Treat anything under 30 trades as a hint, not a result. One good or bad week can move a small sample a long way.
All accounts we provide to our clients are demo accounts with fictitious funds and any trading is in a simulated environment only.